{
  "kind": "ironbridge.disagree.packet",
  "v": 1,
  "fetched_at": "2026-09-12T03:05:11.389Z",
  "unique": "two unmerged public books are allowed to disagree",
  "trail_verify": {
    "code": "S-14",
    "job": "QA / LAW-25 trail verify",
    "organ": "/api/disagree",
    "public_roster": "heartbeat_only"
  },
  "witness_verify": {
    "code": "S-07",
    "job": "Deploy / rollback attest",
    "organ": "witness",
    "public_roster": "heartbeat_only"
  },
  "refusal_verify": {
    "code": "S-15",
    "job": "Improvement / bottleneck hunt",
    "organ": "/api/refusals",
    "public_roster": "heartbeat_only"
  },
  "truth_verify": {
    "code": "S-16",
    "job": "Knowledge graph / truth recon",
    "organ": "/.well-known/operator-truth",
    "public_roster": "heartbeat_only"
  },
  "how_to_verify": "GET books.law25.endpoint and books.seal.endpoint. Compare chain_length and tip_seq to law25_length and seal_tip_seq in this packet. Then: npx -y @ironbridgefoundation/verify abd34fb536e6906e. Save the JSON, flip any prev_hash, run npx -y @ironbridgefoundation/verify --receipt FILE - it must fail. Re-running the rid alone re-fetches the clean copy. This packet does not pick a winner.",
  "winner": null,
  "state": "DISPUTED",
  "law25_length": 12310,
  "seal_tip_seq": 120,
  "disagree": true,
  "books": {
    "law25": {
      "endpoint": "/api/law25/verify",
      "chain_length": 12310,
      "head": {
        "ts": "2026-09-12T02:59:03.747Z",
        "status": "applied",
        "chainlink_prev": "d429a1dc150ef63e1e2812232c6d9ed65fd16cd6a59b969b60cd839bdea34ca7",
        "chainlink_row": "7e49e22e07111f8dcb46309089bc2ef16ab862c18dd9669df407ba60d326d41e"
      }
    },
    "seal": {
      "public_chains": 2,
      "sibling": {
        "name": "LAW-25",
        "endpoint": "/api/law25/verify"
      },
      "note": "two public chains; counts disagree; they are not the same ledger; LAW-25 row=1 leaf_integrity is false",
      "from_seq": 0,
      "limit": 20,
      "tip_seq": 120,
      "known_breaks": [
        {
          "seq": 7,
          "kind": "legacy_prev_hash_discontinuity",
          "note": "Pre-production test-era seal (anchor_day 20614): seq7.prev_hash does not link to seq6.entry_hash. The production chain is continuous from seq8 onward. Historical seals are never rewritten; this single legacy break is disclosed here for full transparency.",
          "production_genesis_seq": 8
        }
      ],
      "rows": [
        {
          "seal_id": "46062a33c6d360b4",
          "content_sha256": "6f79736b6b411bb2657fc2355f4376d8ce8396823a581428a6214e7355201c1a",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "f81bdc97f78f33fa4fa89886d7307d3c8d81326e4e1e7ed5f3ae3442fe61fb39",
          "seq": 0,
          "prev_hash": "GENESIS",
          "entry_hash": "3262d0ac2dfc78b9f720fdad1f3fa7c0dddfba7c3ce397dadb02c231532b1311",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781120393461
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "b16f12da4de69b7b",
          "content_sha256": "d97f56baafca04c16547e080a9ba8b25c74e110cce37cde61fa05f652ad966a1",
          "type_tag": "message",
          "leaf": "a07aa0840bb73f2b1e3f6ea822d68cd61f5df0459fe4724e3fa6a881579928d9",
          "seq": 1,
          "prev_hash": "3262d0ac2dfc78b9f720fdad1f3fa7c0dddfba7c3ce397dadb02c231532b1311",
          "entry_hash": "6ab0af2f6f847e5c86517540b26bd44728e21d891bf962e6f484cdd9007b4931",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781120411630
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "aaab4354dee1c57d",
          "content_sha256": "d97f56baafca04c16547e080a9ba8b25c74e110cce37cde61fa05f652ad966a1",
          "type_tag": "message",
          "leaf": "a07aa0840bb73f2b1e3f6ea822d68cd61f5df0459fe4724e3fa6a881579928d9",
          "seq": 2,
          "prev_hash": "6ab0af2f6f847e5c86517540b26bd44728e21d891bf962e6f484cdd9007b4931",
          "entry_hash": "4116933a2952db71d56cab51b9aef1bac59b247f7aefc36ea9838272a3db532a",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781120412444
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "91ce5f76f6ea8f32",
          "content_sha256": "6f79aa11bb22cc33dd44ee55ff66001122334455667788990011223344551c1a",
          "type_tag": "document",
          "leaf": "8637abe6dee09b6744b000d59ba4550ef31a8d581911f501801a29c40e199a8a",
          "seq": 3,
          "prev_hash": "4116933a2952db71d56cab51b9aef1bac59b247f7aefc36ea9838272a3db532a",
          "entry_hash": "2b9dff2138c05405cf4a1cc203b4bd4205db8cec0713b5aa965c78371213e365",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781120837278
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "d3d17267d0e86e22",
          "content_sha256": "e51946a0695aa11de3d969aab9fc7c94d59affc80a874960ca9d4de428005807",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "bc25fb4d39f203eb4dbdb932868fc1ccdf23075bb041dc6c3af7470cb7e899c7",
          "seq": 4,
          "prev_hash": "2b9dff2138c05405cf4a1cc203b4bd4205db8cec0713b5aa965c78371213e365",
          "entry_hash": "afd644d1a0a487c3f7e7df92a73da76aab41b932a699352a308f2be4a2c34ec3",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781121234102
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "52452cb1fdff7912",
          "content_sha256": "b4ba550a267806f61a992a2c09caeb8132f542a870f5a84021135e23ef7bf5bd",
          "type_tag": "document",
          "leaf": "91bcb215dc65f1257a3ab37a8f0f44489fb315e5281e4df43c52ee690817c11d",
          "seq": 5,
          "prev_hash": "afd644d1a0a487c3f7e7df92a73da76aab41b932a699352a308f2be4a2c34ec3",
          "entry_hash": "bfb75659c8689f8fa03d01a14cfdbd46b0816fdb09975db76eb9e27a29c2aaa1",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781121329070
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "de71e61368da1041",
          "content_sha256": "c63b6819e61f0983318074316158a1b13568e43f6439c30162ad3dbd48cdd2e8",
          "type_tag": "message",
          "leaf": "75ab3cf0e2b622bf1f864f121c4dfbee229fe2e3ee4e1067740a5aae392a9948",
          "seq": 6,
          "prev_hash": "bfb75659c8689f8fa03d01a14cfdbd46b0816fdb09975db76eb9e27a29c2aaa1",
          "entry_hash": "e270b2a64a89ec5ea380c1836c0d88b7eab3044123c88abd2770a979c9ef4b66",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781121430423
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "c866227187de814e",
          "content_sha256": "5f85c62b65fa60a3bf5dd820a0000d291522b9554bece830e4f06994acdc4d23",
          "type_tag": "other",
          "leaf": "d9b741d64544c0843a316c3b4b1a68b5e510927eaa5d6d5daef85f1b21502332",
          "seq": 7,
          "prev_hash": "3411f9adf7cd18ffa7023bc5e7bec91aea02c076ee2ce760931f5d6a29ac019b",
          "entry_hash": "230cb95782bf1c75fb6f8fdb9fc199e309707b123b2129bf1c52f2036baa6b46",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781121482901
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "6ed886cbadb6b599",
          "content_sha256": "0819134bb2654a72326cf9757b0524d1896f66602038a15ea01b8dbd6351e07a",
          "type_tag": "document",
          "leaf": "6e2c2646e282c77098eb8fb917bab2bdb88813f1db3a4e06878ce4542c9764d2",
          "seq": 8,
          "prev_hash": "230cb95782bf1c75fb6f8fdb9fc199e309707b123b2129bf1c52f2036baa6b46",
          "entry_hash": "b1012b10130986e73575b9d251195fee59b94c678ba9e30f44c9cdc052f67495",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781121569917
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "1b2f0fbdd8c9d06b",
          "content_sha256": "c12ab38d76e0312c69b72884665918c63565848ecaec82e386fdd7a39aadc6bf",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "28cec3702dd9ddf2eca9a01293407df7f7934390f22045ecacd4202eeaaed34d",
          "seq": 9,
          "prev_hash": "b1012b10130986e73575b9d251195fee59b94c678ba9e30f44c9cdc052f67495",
          "entry_hash": "1dcb02f4568dc68ae0e26c6e6f191d2cc6caef2b5227667d34f8fff6ffc24262",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781122013515
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "18af0db3200d6038",
          "content_sha256": "7c0cd83adc6d3b4ecf137e05eb67cd51686d742c9b8b4af2de18ff2ab8e87b61",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "988effd97c65f355cdb705075ec245bca3de24640b6764b9c625bde1b867685d",
          "seq": 10,
          "prev_hash": "1dcb02f4568dc68ae0e26c6e6f191d2cc6caef2b5227667d34f8fff6ffc24262",
          "entry_hash": "acc254a6019b3114683f76b8c10e65b53ff31b0b68b46442742ca95a835a9ec4",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781122015020
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "2417374512ddf949",
          "content_sha256": "e3513c91a1544ffa8409c0a1ac28fcf0afebf15449b2439575ee57a67416af7c",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "8c4395ff13a7b207f356a9daa9a0cc27147efb9b460cab6e277401fb6fa847f6",
          "seq": 11,
          "prev_hash": "acc254a6019b3114683f76b8c10e65b53ff31b0b68b46442742ca95a835a9ec4",
          "entry_hash": "68fcd13f24a36edcf60ab22e1bdb68cc94c7f8b46e769fb70c7807cb9c94e2fa",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781122263807
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "ef493c6c9b335c93",
          "content_sha256": "a03f64bb022a6d566ccd004bb77978cbccb29912196d2b8b6db365a15bf75625",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "baf315eb5c43706894aefb3929854070271656cd66a1d3f40796eef5e1415210",
          "seq": 12,
          "prev_hash": "68fcd13f24a36edcf60ab22e1bdb68cc94c7f8b46e769fb70c7807cb9c94e2fa",
          "entry_hash": "bbc513cfc111687664e29439350e1ef506ac03bbc732aa3ba7089096cbfda1a9",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781122465581
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "734664f7eddba8a9",
          "content_sha256": "bab01db1e0843a7129d2a4cefda3365b2bd09d67d62cfb15f757798a76bb2136",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "5fdda0c56f184cf94fb4aa64ab34858c5e384e21d25a0a3a05a54d73ccaccd45",
          "seq": 13,
          "prev_hash": "bbc513cfc111687664e29439350e1ef506ac03bbc732aa3ba7089096cbfda1a9",
          "entry_hash": "74066735cfb2b8542f3229e4f3371a436045d9b8a87677bd49c8a8b076779555",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781122465617
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "64d927ce3f16c21c",
          "content_sha256": "2b7d9b3c1362906c48ab72c68a79079498de47feac973e8eaa311ae6448b832c",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "e073ae1080281438b0c484384ad73aa41bc49d8c99d45f265b5e1b6c2b61e3d6",
          "seq": 14,
          "prev_hash": "74066735cfb2b8542f3229e4f3371a436045d9b8a87677bd49c8a8b076779555",
          "entry_hash": "65eca9ab4bc8ca8cd12336dae35c094ead87f295fee45f5693cb873468cc506a",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781122466339
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "78963b8cc5fba0fb",
          "content_sha256": "84d0b739e0190423847dadc86a7c0939f4bd61390349af56f2a9eb588f2f4634",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "acda3cbac35538cadc1e3f014f478ce4687b403aeed245b9fbb6d0ab7ef41143",
          "seq": 15,
          "prev_hash": "65eca9ab4bc8ca8cd12336dae35c094ead87f295fee45f5693cb873468cc506a",
          "entry_hash": "8931e37f651e742d0128c88566f5fc07e54b3de1232d32de9f2e56908fda1983",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781122586365
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "48d544346b6690a4",
          "content_sha256": "0d405d276aebddbff818bf6edbc93a936ea42b67bdfd37bbc4faebd51292a7df",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "11841c3fabde13cac12fcb8aa2896be1a58e15c51e38f1e039f4070206534235",
          "seq": 16,
          "prev_hash": "8931e37f651e742d0128c88566f5fc07e54b3de1232d32de9f2e56908fda1983",
          "entry_hash": "c7de5451089614d8bd30b77b8e7c24d2a2e2ffd2b3ffe83e1678dcdb50823fc2",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781122586344
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "986ec9657d26ebb6",
          "content_sha256": "04c1eecd864d818e12dbba98dc43e51dcd677dc5870c247ab1b896e3c2028a6a",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "064f8490db04c0263979cdba88fc467b42494958b5ff9b7e9d4e977c534c592c",
          "seq": 17,
          "prev_hash": "c7de5451089614d8bd30b77b8e7c24d2a2e2ffd2b3ffe83e1678dcdb50823fc2",
          "entry_hash": "ea2460cf216b060f045747a7ec8a7935877cb729d14522efac69538107076597",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781122586528
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "32eef0a206fc3843",
          "content_sha256": "410849f028e98fcf2129cbe5ca24b308fa26b5e5623a74f2d60610722cdf2f62",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "810890662b9b3a11be688d900061c457ed5b5b4ca05dedf65a82171091b98005",
          "seq": 18,
          "prev_hash": "ea2460cf216b060f045747a7ec8a7935877cb729d14522efac69538107076597",
          "entry_hash": "1b21ae37cf182599eb28e8bb306cfdf0cba90123df57a8669fcc1bda38bd6fd2",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781122653886
        },
        {
          "seal_id": "73243d5ed298587c",
          "content_sha256": "f907f79cea41d8ae50a666f288dff838607c68aa510aac6bd2c150b258572f68",
          "type_tag": "agreement",
          "leaf": "1a0dca60ef6d2ab75ab997fc8b35fbfceb441ccee26a1d9b5e042b01ec333d54",
          "seq": 19,
          "prev_hash": "1b21ae37cf182599eb28e8bb306cfdf0cba90123df57a8669fcc1bda38bd6fd2",
          "entry_hash": "8f1776803594a4f982e3d57caeb820e166c4f7c5eb9dcf01757cb527769833e9",
          "category": "SEAL_PUBLIC_LEAF",
          "anchor_day": 20614,
          "anchored": false,
          "ts": 1781122654033
        }
      ],
      "endpoint": "/api/chain/page"
    }
  },
  "sample_receipt": {
    "id": "abd34fb536e6906e",
    "operator_self_pay": true,
    "customer_sale": false
  },
  "note": "This packet does not pick a winner. Counts need not match.",
  "_feeds": {
    "witness": "fresh",
    "coldwitness": "fresh",
    "gauntlet": "fresh",
    "witness_age_s": 787,
    "coldwitness_age_s": 787,
    "gauntlet_age_s": 787
  },
  "cold_witness": {
    "vantage": "cold witness (second box, never a signer)",
    "observed_at": "2026-09-12T02:49:01.410Z",
    "age_s": 787,
    "seal": {
      "tip": 120,
      "walked": 120,
      "anchored": 0,
      "known_break": 7,
      "state": "WALKED_WITH_DISCLOSED_BREAK"
    },
    "law25": {
      "len": 12309,
      "head": 12309,
      "continuity_ok": true,
      "relinked_window": 20,
      "state": "RECENT_WINDOW_VERIFIED"
    },
    "anchor": {
      "day": 20260911,
      "sha_match": true,
      "linkage_match": true,
      "state": "ONCHAIN_MATCH"
    },
    "agrees_with_books": {
      "law25_len_delta": -1,
      "seal_tip_delta": 0
    }
  },
  "third_vantage": {
    "label": "never-signer second box",
    "vantage": "cold witness (second box, never a signer)",
    "seal": {
      "tip": 120,
      "walked": 120,
      "anchored": 0,
      "known_break": 7,
      "state": "WALKED_WITH_DISCLOSED_BREAK"
    },
    "law25": {
      "len": 12309,
      "head": 12309,
      "continuity_ok": true,
      "relinked_window": 20,
      "state": "RECENT_WINDOW_VERIFIED"
    },
    "anchor": {
      "day": 20260911,
      "sha_match": true,
      "linkage_match": true,
      "state": "ONCHAIN_MATCH"
    },
    "agrees_with_books": {
      "law25_len_delta": -1,
      "seal_tip_delta": 0
    },
    "edge": {
      "vantage": "second box",
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "detail": "second box vantage: 5x GET 200, 3x lanes POST 402",
      "ts": "2026-09-12T02:52:03.510Z"
    },
    "endpoints": [
      "/api/coldwitness",
      "/api/witness",
      "/api/disagree"
    ]
  },
  "cold_edge": {
    "vantage": "second box",
    "verdict": "PASS",
    "detail": "second box vantage: 5x GET 200, 3x lanes POST 402",
    "ts": "2026-09-12T02:52:03.510Z"
  },
  "gauntlet": {
    "vantage": "second box, external",
    "observed_at": "2026-09-12T02:52:03.510Z",
    "age_s": 787,
    "cases": 6,
    "refused": 6,
    "breaches": 0,
    "all_refused": true
  },
  "how_to_verify_steps": [
    {
      "n": 1,
      "cmd": "curl -s https://ironbridge.foundation/api/law25/verify | jq .chain_length",
      "expect": ">= law25_length in this packet (rows only append)"
    },
    {
      "n": 2,
      "cmd": "curl -s https://ironbridge.foundation/api/chain/page | jq .tip_seq",
      "expect": "== seal_tip_seq"
    },
    {
      "n": 3,
      "cmd": "npx -y @ironbridgefoundation/verify abd34fb536e6906e",
      "expect": "payment PASS on Base RPC, chain PASS; banner PAYMENT+CHAIN VERIFIED (partial) until you pass --result/--request with your own bytes"
    },
    {
      "n": 4,
      "cmd": "curl -s https://ironbridge.foundation/api/receipt/abd34fb536e6906e > r.json; edit one hex character of prev_hash; npx -y @ironbridgefoundation/verify --receipt r.json",
      "expect": "VERIFICATION FAILED - chain (entry_hash no longer binds)"
    },
    {
      "n": 5,
      "cmd": "npx -y @ironbridgefoundation/verify abd34fb536e6906e",
      "expect": "clean copy re-fetched, chain PASS again"
    }
  ],
  "claims_rows": [
    {
      "claim": "Two public books are allowed to disagree",
      "probe": "law25_length != seal_tip_seq",
      "observed": {
        "law25_length": 12310,
        "seal_tip_seq": 120
      },
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "vantage": "edge"
    },
    {
      "claim": "Known breaks are disclosed, never rewritten",
      "probe": "books.seal.known_breaks[0].seq (7) < production_genesis_seq (8)",
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "vantage": "edge"
    },
    {
      "claim": "The sample receipt is operator self-pay, not a sale",
      "probe": "receipt_flags.customer_sale === false",
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "vantage": "edge"
    },
    {
      "claim": "A second box that never signs agrees with both books",
      "probe": "cold_witness present AND seal_tip_delta == 0 AND |law25_len_delta| <= 24",
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "vantage": "second box"
    }
  ],
  "claims_source": [
    "packet-derived"
  ]
}